Game Theory: The Mystery of Minecraft's Haunted Discs (Minecraft)

15 aug 2019
10 094 627 Vaatamised

Get Your New Back To School Theory Wear Here!! ►
Today Theorists, I aim to solve another one of the many mysteries of Minecraft. We've explored a lot already, but with a game this big, there is always more to find. Take the music discs, which are the objects you find randomly throughout the game when you do certain things. Except, there are two discs in particular that peaked my interest - Disc 11 and Disc 13. The two "corrupted" discs that, when you play them, sound like something from a horror game rather than Minecraft. What is going on with Discs 11 and 13? Let's find out!
SUBSCRIBE for More Theories! ►
Get the game here ►►
Need Royalty Free Music for your Content? Try Epidemic Sound.
Get A 30 Day Free Trial! ►
SUBSCRIBE for Every Theory! ►►
Hang out with us on GTLive! ►
#Minecraft #Enderman #Disc11 #Disc13 #Corrupted #Haunted #MinecraftTheory #Theory #GameTheory
The TRUTH About MINECRAFT’s World! ►►
The END of Princess Peach! ►
Minecraft's Ending, DECODED! ►►
Mario Kart 8, Mario's SCARIEST Game? ►
What's Diamond Armor Worth IRL? ►►
Writers: Matthew Patrick
Editors: BanditRants, Tyler Mascola, Dan "Cybert" Seibert, and Alex "Sedge" Sedgwick
Assistant Editor: AlyssaBeCrazy
Sound Editor: Yosi Berman

  • and who would've known that the sweet tunes I was cranking in my epic base held so much hidden lore

    gaydes69gaydes69Aasta tagasi
    • LOL

      Amy ScraggAmy Scragg2 päeva tagasi
    • lol

      Unverified IdiotUnverified Idiot5 päeva tagasi
    • Wait What tunes

      David GavrilescuDavid Gavrilescu9 päeva tagasi
    • @S.S Dinghy WAT DA FOOK

      Be BopBe Bop17 päeva tagasi
    • yes

      NoobecstadicNoobecstadic21 päev tagasi
  • When I whacked this I was so excited bc I LOVE minecraft

    Courtney ReedCourtney Reed30 minutit tagasi
  • What happens if we make the destroyer disc 11

    Tania OuzouniTania Ouzouni4 tundi tagasi
    • Remake

      Tania OuzouniTania Ouzouni4 tundi tagasi
  • Here is my theory: Why zombiefied piglins are immune to lava although they are undead mobs

  • Hey man I love your fnaf , among us and minecraft vids and I'm subbed I recommend the story line of the dream smp it has a infinite timeline lul

    Time LeszTime Lesz8 tundi tagasi
  • Minecraft should be rated M but because of the graphics its rated e+10

    mr. penguinmr. penguin8 tundi tagasi

    Hikaru YaminariHikaru Yaminari9 tundi tagasi
  • good edit didnt scared

    Rafiq gamerRafiq gamer12 tundi tagasi
  • 13 is my lucky number...

    WeebmysterWeebmyster14 tundi tagasi
  • When mat pat says about the ancient builders disappearing and so could we actually makes sense because in hardcore if we die our world gets deleted as if it was the end of the world, the extinction of builders. Us as the player are the world's only hope because sure some villages have golems but it's sometimes not enough to defend the villagers and we also know the villagers aren't that good at farming. We are the only chance of the world's survival. and I hope mat pat is reading this and if he is, you may call me the Comment Theorist and by the way I'm still terrified of those two disk they should be in fnaf anyway I've wanted to do my own theory so tell me your thoughts and I'll show it in this same video in the comments

    Chingon MasChingon Mas15 tundi tagasi
  • *Heavy* - I fear no man but that thing... *pans to disc 11* *Heavy* - It scares me

    Blake ShaverBlake Shaver18 tundi tagasi
  • I'm going to extend MatPat's theory a little bit more. Up to the point of disc 13 where skeletons are shooting, he was right. After that, a faint cry for help can be heard. slot in disc 11 and from my several years of experience, sounds like me when I am getting overwhelmed by mobs and placing dirt blocks to protect myself and/or speed bridging over a ravine. A creeper then drops down from a cave above and explodes on the bridge, knocking the adventurer into the water below in the ravine. the heavy swimming seems like an extremely injured person and leads me to believe that they must have crawled out of the water, because the lack of footsteps. the adventurer finds a place to rest and checks their inventory, where disc 11 was shattered by the arrow from the skeleton (if the creeper broke it, there would be more pieces). the flint and steel sound references making a fire at the bottom to warm up and the rustling noise gives the impression of recording findings in a journal like you said. I then arrive at my conclusion, that the adventurer stumbled upon something that should not have been seen, leading him to be chased by the skeletons and creeper. there is a faint enderman noise, giving the idea that through the runic language of the crafting table, the enderman was giving the execution order to the skeletons. in the end, the adventurer disappeared without a trace because the mobs found him and killed him, taking the stuff as spoils, creating the first armored and armed mobs, leading to the evolution of zombies being able to pick up gear from a players dead corpse. But that's just a theory, A GAME THEORY. thanks for reading my long analysis of your video and I love your videos, so keep doing them. the cynical nature that they give off brightens my day for invoking the "it can always be worse" sentiment. =1

    Blake ShaverBlake Shaver19 tundi tagasi
  • 😂 Shameless merchandising!! 😂

    Sam UrnessSam Urness21 tund tagasi
  • Wow. Will he ever stop ruining our childhoods?

    Falloutboi 24Falloutboi 2423 tundi tagasi
  • What is the origin of the enderman.

    Falloutboi 24Falloutboi 24Päev tagasi
  • Read this off a Reddit post and guess what.. It adds up a lot! Steve than appears in the world. He finds the builder's constructions and explores them. Then he discovers Disk 11 which is an audio recording of someone(A builder) trying to escape from the wither or his mobs and disk 13 that I think is a bell ringing telling the builders that they are under attack. If you put the 2 disks together, what I think you hear is someone trying to escape from the mobs/wither while the bell rings telling us that they are under attack. In the end, he's caught.

    Bryan SteinerBryan SteinerPäev tagasi
  • play them at the same time

    Megastalker GamingMegastalker GamingPäev tagasi
  • Does no one notice the enderman scream as the creeper explodes?? Like or reply if you heard 👍👇

    Riot CakeRiot CakePäev tagasi
  • What is cave sounds mean?

    Marianita DiocenaMarianita DiocenaPäev tagasi
  • Whenever i punch a zombie in minecraft i hear this i hear zombie and brine why brine is the short for herobrine herobrine's the glitch the cursed the games code i fear herobrine you do not want me say the details of herobrine

    Matteo RampasMatteo RampasPäev tagasi
  • I know something about disc11 is that I heard it backwards and it sounded like someone was running from something something unnatural it sounded like that he was running from preacher a virus

    Jackson MasonJackson MasonPäev tagasi
  • If you thought disc 11 was from herobrine ur a true veteran

    jj bluegumjj bluegumPäev tagasi
  • H E A V Y W E A P O N S G U Y F E A R S N O M A N but that thing... It scares him.

    Finn FosterFinn FosterPäev tagasi
  • if endermen are builders after they evolved in the end then how did they get eyes of ender for the first end portal ??????????

    Chloe BluntChloe BluntPäev tagasi
  • *Jumpscare warning at **0:30*

    Jake RozewiczJake RozewiczPäev tagasi
  • This will probably help you find something out put this 13 and then put this 11 and then combine them and then you might find something

    General Frost 2323General Frost 2323Päev tagasi
  • I don’t know if you already discussed this in the zombies video but did you notice that zombies in Minecraft with the same clothes as Steve

    General Frost 2323General Frost 2323Päev tagasi
  • Someone should do the sound thingy and make a rickroll link

    S KS KPäev tagasi
  • As a Minecraft player I will never look at this game again the same

    AndromomAndromomPäev tagasi
  • Just to let you know at the end of 11 you can hear an enderman before the explosion.

    Timmy BaylorTimmy BaylorPäev tagasi
  • I LOVED THAT THEORY like always

    Sugar and Spice SistersSugar and Spice Sisters2 päeva tagasi
  • Disc 11 Disc 12 Disc 13

    سمية حافظسمية حافظ2 päeva tagasi
  • Yeah i think that guy is chased by a Herobrine .Here is my theory:So as we now Herobrine used to dig 2x2 tunnels (when he excited at least ) and that journalist or author-what ever you wanna call him ,started exploring that tunnel and he found a cave .Then he realised he is being chased by him.... Herobrine he ran towards the end escaping from creeper and skeleton then he fell to water blabbla bla etc. Now here is why i think it's Herobrine: Yo can't find any cave which is located near water or starts with dirt. Unless is a tunnel.... I don't know if this is true or even near the truth but that's just my theory

    Flame Swords10Flame Swords102 päeva tagasi
  • This is a bad time to feel like I'm being watched...

    hopesworld 9hopesworld 92 päeva tagasi
  • Arrows must hit All Californians

    Super MarioSuper Mario2 päeva tagasi
  • yes, my favorite mob *Men Men*

    HuneeBruh ExistsHuneeBruh Exists2 päeva tagasi
  • Do Minecraft Lego's Count as canon?

    lomax99999lomax999992 päeva tagasi
  • this video makes so much more sence

    mykah gallagosmykah gallagos2 päeva tagasi
  • Minecraft is scarier than fnaf

    Erik WalshErik Walsh2 päeva tagasi
  • can you do a vid on the creepers orgin?

    oh nooh no3 päeva tagasi
  • Maybe we will find more about it the cave update

    M CM C3 päeva tagasi
  • Whos herobrine? is he a boss in minecraft

    Mr noodleMr noodle3 päeva tagasi
    • Thanks for the information

      Mr noodleMr noodle2 päeva tagasi
    • Herobrine was a so called “glitch” back in the earlier days of minecraft. It is steve but with white eyes and people have made theories and said Herobrine has come into their world. You can look it up.

      dj idkdj idk2 päeva tagasi
  • I don't see anything between a arrow and the sound of the disk

    Omar animatorOmar animator3 päeva tagasi
  • Im watching this when its night time, and i just got goosebumps

    Peyton ZibrowskiPeyton Zibrowski3 päeva tagasi
  • Oh hey! Also, the disc name "11" is a reference to how many discs were in the game when it was made.

    some random dude that plays robloxsome random dude that plays roblox3 päeva tagasi
  • I’m 10 and everytime I hear it I thought the guy died- but okay-

    randomshift max the catrandomshift max the cat3 päeva tagasi
  • Another thing is that the discs are named after creeper based events like cat, which is what creeper are scared of, blocks because that's what creepers blow up and wait, as in they wait for their prey.

    UnsafePyeUnsafePye3 päeva tagasi
  • what if the coughing meant there was a sickness

    Catrina OnderdonkCatrina Onderdonk3 päeva tagasi
  • Better to taaake a stand, that was when I ruled the land 15:46 oooooooooooooooooooh

    harry fraylingharry frayling4 päeva tagasi
  • This theory is cool and creepy

    ChainSaw 97ChainSaw 974 päeva tagasi
  • Even tommy doesn't want these disks

    Temporary Channel nameTemporary Channel name4 päeva tagasi
  • Theory of disc 11 and 13 Not a full theory but have you noticed that In the center of all the music disks there are things that look like eyes? And disc 11 is shattered, like eyes of ender do sometimes when you throw them. idk what it fits into but its part of a theory.

    Cube WorksCube Works4 päeva tagasi
  • and disc 11 i think is someone running from a creeper

    Turtleboy gamingTurtleboy gaming4 päeva tagasi
  • i played disc 11 in the gap between disc 13 and it strangely completely fits

    Turtleboy gamingTurtleboy gaming4 päeva tagasi
  • It scared me so much xD

    Starletax21Starletax214 päeva tagasi
  • Lots of years ago, I started a new world in minecraft. I usually play with the bonus chest option, where you usually get some tools, some wood, some food and some torches. That day, I found something else, because inside I found a broken disk. I was kind of bothered by it, but I kept playing, normaly. I made a hole inside a mountain so I could have a safe place to strip-mine during the night. Meanwhile I was building a sweet house near an adorable lake behind a jungle, putting almost all materials I could get to build it. When finally I found diamonds, I remembered about the broken disk, so I made a jubox to hear it. So i crafted it and I place it in the basically finished home. What I heard was unsettling. The next day, my house was finished enough that I could start living there, abandoning my old house-mine, but still unsettled by the disk I started to hear things. Every now and then I would hear creepy sounds. Cave sounds. They did bothered me a lot, because they were pretty frequent. Not even when exploring a cave you hear that much noises. This made me think of the disk, on what was on it, on how it was found. That world was cursed. Then I started linking dots. There were more cave sounds than in an actual cave, there were almost no mob sounds, just complete silence, not even music when I was home and the chest with the disk was still in that corner of the house where cave noises where more frequent. I cancelled that world

    TheCarloCarloneTheCarloCarlone4 päeva tagasi
  • If all the other builders died y do we respawn when we die if the previous players died forever how can we come back to life after death

    Kai MathewKai Mathew4 päeva tagasi
  • Creepers with arms is without the doubt the most cursed thing I've ever seen

    JeremyTheFoxJeremyTheFox4 päeva tagasi
  • July 30th is birthday i turned 1 that year

    mj thegodmj thegod4 päeva tagasi
  • I never found this... So if i find it i gonna drop it into lava

    Parsa RezvanParsa Rezvan5 päeva tagasi
  • My Theory:herobrine is a corrupted file of steve like the creepers there just pigs but corrupted

    GalaxyPlayzGalaxyPlayz5 päeva tagasi
  • Your theory scared ne lmao but its okay😁😁😁

    Anime AceAnime Ace5 päeva tagasi
  • Matpat when i found my first dungeon the chest had the musics disc 13 on the 13th of october and then the next october 11 i got it in a dungeon i think im haunted

    Fortunata OcampoFortunata Ocampo5 päeva tagasi
  • I was alone in my basement when he played the audio

    EvaGraingerEvaGrainger5 päeva tagasi

    Kirill RakitinKirill Rakitin5 päeva tagasi
  • The day before my birthday last year!!!

    4g3t 4moon3r4g3t 4moon3r5 päeva tagasi
  • When it has the fake blue screen I actually thought my pc crashed 🤣

    Pug LifePug Life5 päeva tagasi
  • "Sometimes the smallest things take up the most room in your heart." -Winnie the Pooh

    the blue robloxian !the blue robloxian !5 päeva tagasi
  • I believe that we ARE the explores since when you spawn your in one random spot or the spot YOU ran to

    CheesiePatatosCheesiePatatos5 päeva tagasi
  • Stop it stop doing 13 and 11

    steven hallsteven hall6 päeva tagasi
  • My opinion. Jeb and his cat recorded the disc 11 & 13

    Rocky DeveraRocky Devera6 päeva tagasi
  • What if the zombies are just the dead versions of Steve

    Jeremy GomezJeremy Gomez6 päeva tagasi
  • wow i got this music disc 11 too

    sam braysam bray6 päeva tagasi
  • i have a question.... if the first master builders made a portel to H*ll why cant they make a portal to heven?

  • There’s something I don’t understand . if Steve was alone.. who is Alex?

    Power Rangers Sea ForcePower Rangers Sea Force6 päeva tagasi
  • If it's broken, how can you play it? And even more, how did it continue to record?

    רפאל כהןרפאל כהן7 päeva tagasi
  • Oh my god imagining vanishing into thin air while playing Minecraft!

    Flory KraperFlory Kraper7 päeva tagasi
  • Why I hear my name, I am innocent but don't worry I escaped the Nether

    NicholasCool 689NicholasCool 6897 päeva tagasi
  • I think I’ll just stick with cat

    BlobmationsBlobmations7 päeva tagasi
  • When your at a science convention and you hear hey that’s just a theory a game theory

    riely martinezriely martinez7 päeva tagasi
  • What’s ur favorite music disc? Mine is cat

    Jack BJack B7 päeva tagasi
  • I thought the steps of running on stone and dirt was a mob braking stone and dirt wildly to get to its target.

    Jude MorrisJude Morris7 päeva tagasi
  • what disc 13 is broken and 11

    Alexander PetittAlexander Petitt7 päeva tagasi
  • I never knew disc 11 was broken

    CBandD cReAtIoNsCBandD cReAtIoNs7 päeva tagasi
  • Didnt a guy on reddit figure this out like 5 years ago

    GuzzlerGuzzler7 päeva tagasi
  • I think its just me who plays 11 and 13 together. Also they should have added disc in 2011

  • Disc 11 and 13 put it in a juckbocks parrot start dancing

    Marc Denhilz De GuzmanMarc Denhilz De Guzman8 päeva tagasi
  • * HELLLO *

    Influence XDInfluence XD8 päeva tagasi
  • I found it as a kid and I was like this is wierd and someone is going to find what it is

    the icecream spythe icecream spy8 päeva tagasi
  • When I was seven, I would build trashy mansion's in my Xbox 360 worlds. Every time I had a friend over, I would make them listen to disc 11 while giving them a brief tour of my birch plank mansion. I want a word with my younger self...

    Eva TanEva Tan8 päeva tagasi
  • Disc 13 is actually my fav

    • @the icecream spy yay now I know I'm not the only weird one listening to weird music

    • Same

      the icecream spythe icecream spy8 päeva tagasi
  • Mat pat “you have no hands! " Mii creaper :are you sure about that?!

    Chris the ultra gamerChris the ultra gamer8 päeva tagasi

    Clark Kayden GapayClark Kayden Gapay8 päeva tagasi

    Clark Kayden GapayClark Kayden Gapay8 päeva tagasi
  • Well I’m not gonna play Minecraft for a hike niw

    Vasantha ArunVasantha Arun8 päeva tagasi
  • I wonder why creepers drop music discs when killed by a skeleton arrow in the first place... did someone (maybe the ancient builders/people who recorded the discs) implant them into the creepers body? And why only when a skeleton arrow kills it? Maybe when the player kills a creeper the disc inside it gets destroyed, only when a skeleton arrow kills it the disc does not get destroyed?

    Salam - PeaceSalam - Peace8 päeva tagasi
  • I have a theory. What if you were that person who was in the music discs and you got trapped somewhere like in a cave during a cave in and you wake up after years and years and you lost your memory so you are the last person alive... (Its a weird theory I know)

    Love The Ender womanLove The Ender woman8 päeva tagasi
  • July 30th 2010 was my birthday

    Kathy PiuntiKathy Piunti8 päeva tagasi
  • And disck13

    Kathy PiuntiKathy Piunti8 päeva tagasi
  • That freaked me out bro

    Brian McKnightBrian McKnight8 päeva tagasi